I made two versions, one with AI and one by hand (READ DESC)

I used AI to create motion graphics, as a test. After what everyone has been saying online about it, if it's really that good, it should be able to replicate any style and any video, right? Instead of just telling it to create a video for this song, I first brainstormed the exact scenes, including background text, transitions, effects, and a huge file outlining exactly what I might do for a style like this. I even provided it a reference animation to copy the exact style of... but it falls really short: [https://www.reddit.com/u/UltFireSword/s/SlB2fykauS](https://www.reddit.com/u/UltFireSword/s/SlB2fykauS) (AI VERSION) In the end, it took about 2 hours with claude opus 5.5 max, and looks really bad imo. Unfortunately I know the capabilities of AI (I'm also a software developer), and it seems likely that in a few years time, AI will have gotten so good that it *literally* can do anything that a human does... but at least for the time being, I personally think AI still sucks at these…